Free Membership
Newsletter
Help
Subscribe
Sign In
Search
June 8, 2023
All times are Vienna time
Search
Subscribe
Sign In
Countries:
Africa »
Algeria Angola Benin Botswana Burundi Côte d'Ivoire Ethiopia Ghana Guinea Kenya Lesotho Liberia Libya Mali Mauritius Morocco Mozambique Namibia Niger Nigeria Rwanda South Africa Sudan Tanzania The Congo Togo Tunisia Uganda Zambia Zimbabwe
Asia-Pacific »
Afghanistan Australia Bangladesh Cambodia China Hong Kong SAR India Indonesia Japan Laos Malaysia Mongolia Myanmar Nepal New Zealand North Korea (DPRK) Pakistan Philippines Singapore South Korea Sri Lanka Taiwan Thailand Vietnam
Central- & Eastern Europe »
Albania Bosnia & Herzegovina Bulgaria Croatia Czech Rep. Estonia Georgia Hungary Kosovo Latvia Lithuania North Macedonia Montenegro Poland Romania Serbia Slovakia Slovenia Ukraine Western Balkans
Middle East »
Egypt Iran Iraq Israel Jordan Kuwait Lebanon Oman Palestinian Territories Qatar Saudi Arabia Syria Turkey United Arab Emirates Yemen
Russia & CIS »
Russia Armenia Azerbaijan Belarus Kazakhstan Kyrgyzstan Moldova Turkmenistan Uzbekistan
The Americas »
Argentina Bolivia Brazil Canada Central America Chile Colombia Cuba Ecuador Mexico Panama Paraguay Peru The Caribbean Uruguay Venezuela
United States
Western Europe »
Belgium Cyprus Denmark Finland France Germany Greece Iceland Ireland Italy Liechtenstein Luxembourg Malta Monaco Norway Portugal Scotland Spain Sweden Switzerland The Netherlands United Kingdom Vatican City
Business:
Economy
Economic Policies
Investing in Austria
Securities
Earnings
Foreign Trade
Deals
Legal Issues
More Business & Economics+
Politics:
Domestic
Brussels
International
Diplomacy
Companies:
Professional Services »
Banks Financial Services Real Estate Insurance Other Services
Energy »
Oil & Gas Utilities Renewables Mining
Industrials »
Construction Automotive Industrial Goods Basic Resources Chemicals Other Industrials
Transport »
Airlines & Airports Shipping Rail Road
Retail & Consumer
Health Care
Technology
Telecoms
Media
Tourism
Other
Organizations:
Diplomatic Missions
International Organizations
Other
People:
Executives
Politicians
Diplomats
Entrepreneurs
Other
Lifestyle & Travel:
Culture
Travel
Personal Real Estate
Health
Food & Drink
Luxury Goods
More+
More+:
Events
Photo Galleries
Videos
Classifieds
Work & Careers
More+
Home
Countries
Business
Politics
Diplomacy
Companies
Organizations
People
Lifestyle & Travel
More+
Africa
Algeria
Angola
Benin
Botswana
Burundi
Côte d'Ivoire
Ethiopia
Ghana
Guinea
Kenya
Lesotho
Liberia
Libya
Mali
Mauritius
Morocco
Mozambique
Namibia
Niger
Nigeria
Rwanda
South Africa
Sudan
Tanzania
The Congo
Togo
Tunisia
Uganda
Zambia
Zimbabwe
Asia-Pacific
Afghanistan
Australia
Bangladesh
Cambodia
China
Hong Kong SAR
India
Indonesia
Japan
Laos
Malaysia
Mongolia
Myanmar
Nepal
New Zealand
North Korea (DPRK)
Pakistan
Philippines
Singapore
South Korea
Sri Lanka
Taiwan
Thailand
Vietnam
Central- & Eastern Europe
Albania
Bosnia & Herzegovina
Bulgaria
Croatia
Czech Rep.
Estonia
Georgia
Hungary
Kosovo
Latvia
Lithuania
North Macedonia
Montenegro
Poland
Romania
Serbia
Slovakia
Slovenia
Ukraine
Western Balkans
Middle East
Egypt
Iran
Iraq
Israel
Jordan
Kuwait
Lebanon
Oman
Palestinian Territories
Qatar
Saudi Arabia
Syria
Turkey
United Arab Emirates
Yemen
Russia & CIS
Russia
Armenia
Azerbaijan
Belarus
Kazakhstan
Kyrgyzstan
Moldova
Turkmenistan
Uzbekistan
The Americas
Argentina
Bolivia
Brazil
Canada
Central America
Chile
Colombia
Cuba
Ecuador
Mexico
Panama
Paraguay
Peru
The Caribbean
Uruguay
Venezuela
United States
Western Europe
Belgium
Cyprus
Denmark
Finland
France
Germany
Greece
Iceland
Ireland
Italy
Liechtenstein
Luxembourg
Malta
Monaco
Norway
Portugal
Scotland
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland
The Netherlands
United Kingdom
Vatican City
Economy
Economic Policies
Investing in Austria
Securities
Earnings
Foreign Trade
Deals
Legal Issues
More Business & Economics+
Domestic
Brussels
International
Professional Services
Banks
Financial Services
Real Estate
Insurance
Other Services
Energy
Oil & Gas
Utilities
Renewables
Mining
Industrials
Construction
Automotive
Industrial Goods
Basic Resources
Chemicals
Other Industrials
Transport
Airlines & Airports
Shipping
Rail
Road
Retail & Consumer
Health Care
Technology
Telecoms
Media
Tourism
Other
Diplomatic Missions
International Organizations
Other
Executives
Politicians
Diplomats
Entrepreneurs
Other
Culture
Travel
Personal Real Estate
Health
Food & Drink
Luxury Goods
More+
Events
Photo Galleries
Videos
Classifieds
Work & Careers
More+
Latest News
Ukrainian War
Covid in Austria
USA in Vienna
UK in Vienna
Russia in Vienna
China in Vienna
Iran in Vienna
UN
OSCE
IAEA
OPEC
Sponsored Content
Tweet
Share

Ibiza Affair Committee Concludes in National Council: How Corrupt are Austrian Politicians?

More+ › More+ ♦ Published: September 23, 2021; 14:17 ♦ (Vindobona)
Sponsored Content

How corruptible is Austrian politics? This question was explored by the deputies in the National Council session when discussing the recently published final report of the Ibiza-Affair Investigation Committee. Although the report was unanimously acknowledged, the parties were far apart in their conclusions.

Ibiza Affair: Parties discuss controversial final report in Austrian National Council. (Picture: Inaugural Session of the Austrian National Council, Oct. 2019.) / Picture: © Parlamentsdirektion / Johannes Zinner

The Social Democratic Party (SPÖ) and the NEOS, on whose initiative the committee on "alleged venality of the black-blue government", which was launched in 2020, had been set up, found that the investigations had been terminated prematurely. In particular, the connections to the ÖVP in state institutions would have to be examined more closely in order to deal with cases of possible abuse of power. The FPÖ also sees the investigation work as confirming that the Turkish People's Party has a network in the ministries that wants to seize power in the state; the investigation work is therefore by no means over. 

For the ÖVP, on the other hand, the committee has removed the basis for allegations of corruption against the first government under Chancellor Sebastian Kurz. Rather, it was now obvious how much the system of the U-committee needed to be reformed in order to protect its work from abuse. The Greens saw the investigative committee as a successful political self-cleansing process. The committee had produced numerous findings. Unlike the associated report, however, these findings would not be shelved, the deputies emphasized.

Before the start of the debate, Doris Bures, the presiding Second Speaker of the National Council, formally declared the committee of inquiry closed. In eleven chapters, the debated report outlines the investigations of the committee, which was set up in response to the Ibiza video with Heinz-Christian Strache that became public in 2019. The meeting between the then FPÖ chairman and an alleged Russian oligarch's daughter, which was secretly filmed on the Spanish vacation island Ibiza before the 2017 National Council elections, may have been a trap, but it raised the questions dealt with in the committee of inquiry: Had corruption, embezzlement and abuse of office occurred under the ÖVP-FPÖ coalition formed after the 2017 parliamentary elections?

Sponsored Content

ÖVP sees allegations invalidated

From the point of view of the ÖVP in the committee of inquiry, the final report of the trial judge has refuted the allegations. "This Ibiza investigation committee was unfortunately an insinuation committee," Andreas Hanger said, referring to investigations surrounding alleged party donations via ÖVP-affiliated associations. There had never been any cases of law-buying. However, the scandalization of the investigated cases often violated the privacy of the persons named, Hanger stated, who therefore spoke out in favor of a change in the committee procedure. For example, the subject of the investigation must be more clearly defined and the premature disclosure of sensitive documents to the media must be prevented in the future. This would strengthen the investigative committee as an important control instrument and make it less susceptible to abuse.

SPÖ and FPÖ denounce "Turkish parallel society

On behalf of the SPÖ, Kai Jan Krainer said in the plenum that the ÖVP was apparently living in an aloof "parallel society" that did not want to recognize the facts. The investigation committee demanded by the SPÖ and NEOS had shown that the "Kurz-Strache government" could be bought. Donation payments in exchange for political favors and incidents of post cheating had come to light. The main protagonists in the Ibiza video, Heinz-Christian Strache and his former party colleague Johann Gudenus, are no longer in politics, but the "Kurz system" still exists, Krainer accused Chancellor Sebastian Kurz and his entourage of attempts to gain control in state institutions such as the Ministry of Finance through their own network away from the leadership level: "This shows power and abuse of power by this group," which does not allow any criticism.

Similar to Krainer, FPÖ member Christian Hafenecker also accused the ÖVP of continually obstructing the work of the committee. The People's Party had been very interested in "covering up" facts in the committee, Hafenecker said indignantly, and considered this an "attack on parliamentarianism". Among other things he reminded of the from its view highly questionable procedures approximately around the occupation of the executive committee Thomas Schmid in the Austrian holding corporation (ÖBAG), in order to stress, a follow-up committee is absolutely necessary. In addition, the Greens and their role in the Vienna Heumarktprojekt should be examined more closely, Hafenecker found.

The findings of the committee represent an important basis, expressed Nina Tomaselli (Greens), which could also be used for another committee of inquiry. Whether and when there will be a next committee of inquiry, however, has not yet been decided, despite widespread criticism.

It is a concern of the ÖVP to conduct politics at a high level in order to maintain the trust of the population. Therefore Ernst Gödl (ÖVP) recommended the other parties to use the "pause for reflection" until the next investigation committee and to refrain from insinuations, scandalizations and personal attacks in the future.

Demand for live transmission of the questioning in the investigation committee

Maria Holzleitner (SPÖ) located a "mocking rejection towards the parliament" from Chancellor Kurz. The Austrian People's Party (ÖVP) was trying to talk down the instrument of the investigative committee, she emphasized, and wanted to bring "light into the darkness" by means of live transmissions of the questioning in the investigative committee. A motion for a resolution to this effect was rejected, as was a motion to save the files available to the investigative committee from shredding. The SPÖ, FPÖ and NEOS argue that since the end of the Ibiza Investigation Committee would also mean the end of the legal basis entitling the National Council to dispose of the files presented, the 2.7 million pages of files would be threatened with destruction. They demand their safekeeping, especially since the opposition parties want to continue the investigation committee.

NEOS: Investigations can be kept small or even accelerated

Sponsored Content

While the ÖVP always emphasized that there was no venality, the SPÖ and NESO accused the government at the time of just that. The committee of inquiry should hold politics accountable, emphasized Stephanie Krisper (NEOS). Two years ago, together with MP Krainer, the MP had initiated the request for the establishment of the U-committee, and today accused the ÖVP of preventing, delaying and dragging out the process. In the investigation committee she had experienced many obstructions by ÖVP respondents. For example, Chancellor Sebastian Kurz's extravagant answers to questions from his own party, which meant that there was no question time left for the other parties. Krisper stressed that the ÖVP had done everything in its power to torpedo investigations against its own party in exchange for speeding up investigations in other areas. She went on to call for reforms such as measures against post-hunting and anti-corruption measures.

More transparency in contacts between politics and business

Among the committee's findings from its investigations is the report's recommendation to separate government administration and legislation from the interests of private-sector companies and to limit official contacts in this context to what is necessary. In addition, meetings, discussions and agreements between political representatives and company executives should be recorded in the files. With regard to the Casinos Austria complex in particular, the report states that the Ministry of Finance should restrict its activities in the field of gaming to legal matters, player protection and the granting of licenses. Tenders for concessions and licenses, the administration of shares and the rights arising from the federal government's shareholdings should, as far as possible, be handled by an independent body to be set up.

In order to curb the evasion of the obligation to report party donations, associations in which persons close to a party are active or which are ideologically close to a party should in principle be recorded as "party-affiliated organizations," the report states with regard to donations that are not brought to the attention of the Court of Audit.

Austrian Parliament

Copyright © Vindobona. You may share using our article tools. Please don't cut articles from Vindobona and redistribute by email or post to the web.
Sponsored Content
Fast News Search
Related News
Austria's Ex-Vice Chancellor Strache Found Guilty of Corruption (August 27, 2021)
Ibizagate: New Book Proves Allegations Against Former Freedom Party Leader Strache (August 22, 2019)
Ibiza-Video - New Elections in Austria after Vice Chancellor Resignation (May 18, 2019)
Read More
Thomas Schmid, Stephanie Krisper, SPOE, Sebastian Kurz, OEBAG - Austria Holding PLC - Oesterreichische Beteiligungs AG, NEOS, Nina Tomaselli, Kai Jan Krainer, Johann Gudenus, Ibizagate, CASAG Casinos Austria AG, Christian Hafenecker, Doris Bures, Ernst Goedl, FPOE, Green Party, Heinz Christian Strache, BMF - Federal Ministry of Finance - Bundesministerium für Finanzen, Andreas Hanger, Austrian Parliament, ACA Austrian Court of Audit - Rechnungshof
Featured
See latest Vindobona Newsletter
Sign up now for full site access and to read a limited amount of free premium articles per month:
Sign Up
×
Sponsored Content
Sponsored Content
©1995-2023 Vindobona
Contact
Help
Imprint
Press
Careers
Partners
Terms & Conditions
Site Security
Privacy
Sitemap
Advertise
About Us